Tuesday, April 8, 2008

"Who Killed the Electric Car?"

Upon seeing this video, as an engineer, I was outraged. I understand that, within a company, the people who do the finances and the people who actually do the engineering probably don’t interact with each other aside from those in charge of the financial planning for individual projects. With that said, I highly doubt that such effective and revolutionary (yet ugly, lol) cars were being developed as the head engineers knew that this would not be profitable post-production due to its overly successful, low-cost-demanding post-purchase performance. Overall, after finishing the EV1, they probably held their heads in shame because something so well engineering simply went to waste- literally.

The question: “Could I as an engineer ever be on a team that executes a project so well that it is simply not profitable?”

Fortunately, I recently attended an engineering career fair at which I had the ever so delightful opportunity to indict and pose this question to each of Ford Motor Company, Toyota, Honda, Nissan, Mercedes-Benz and GM.

While some gave me very generic, scripted answers about something that I didn’t even ask (e.g. hydrogen fuel cells, gas emissions, “going green”….uggghhh, shut up), I got the most straightforward and comprehensive answers from our very own GM and Ford. I had actually talked to the representative from Toyota before the guy from Ford informed me that the reason Toyota can afford to have the most hybrids out today is that they pay unethical wages to workers overseas.

So almost two decades later, we see the same result: these cars cost the company money with each sale, and the difference back then was that an all electric car proves more costly since it requires less service after sale. GM pretty much straight up told me that they made a mistake by abruptly killing the electric car (and gained points with me by acknowledging that they value learning from their mistakes). The difference between each of the companies is how they marginalize the loss due to sale of these current day electric cars and the gains made from the other respective areas in which they excel.

So, it turns out that these companies, as demonstrated then and now, can afford to make a product whose banner motto is not “planned obsolescence” without going bankrupt or drastically sinking below the competition. They just choose not too in greed, and they take the much-emblazoned path of choosing what is fiscally lazy every time technology and ethics seem to clash.

No comments: