Tuesday, April 15, 2008

"the convenient untruths"

It does indeed feel good to hear information that agrees with what you think you know- either you know you’re right, or you’re wrong but still know you’re right because a million other people say so. It’s a win-win situation. I myself can clearly see how I, along with the rest of society, undoubtedly embrace only the information that confirms or fits nicely with my own unwavering, stubborn opinion. Nowadays, we don’t even believe the scientists.

While facts usually aren’t as simple as the percentages and pie graphs that represent them, every member of society is guilty of extracting only what helps his or her argument. This happens on a day to day basis, and people rarely get called out for it (e.g. “the weed separated Constance and Gordon” or “Vanderbilt is cheap” or “the Patriots are unbeatable”- all opinions that aren’t necessarily true but could be seen as fact until suppressed or unknown contradictory information surfaces). The question should be if this is simple, harmless human nature or, on the contrary, a cause for concern in a modern society in which the thoughts of one can reach and affect so many. Not only do variations in new forms of media in current society allow for one to seek out and verify his/her opinion in outlets such as cable news, blogs, and talk radio, as pointed out by segment interviewee Farhad Manjoo, the ease of actually broadcasting an opinion (such as in this very moment) allows for that search for similar opinions to be possible. Fifty years ago, the main connection that could be made was through direct contact and shared information was not documented, whereas now, everything said is available to the masses forever.

It’s interesting to point out how Manjoo found that Conservatives are more likely to not pay attention to contrasting views (hmm…). Returning to my question, is this just harmless human nature, or is it a cause for concern? It is both, but when this human aspect is an ignored aspect of a bi-partisan government, it is a cause for concern because there is no powerful balance for the mass of similar thinking. Should we have gone to Iraq? [And only to be fair…] Should gays have the same marriage rights? They’re questions that go essentially unanswered when input and power of control comes from only one side. Aside from the nobility and openness of each individual, the fact that people with opinions run countries is more than enough to try to be more open to information regardless of our opinions. We really need to turn this society from being so opinionated (and subsequently ignorant and judgmental) to being more informed.

No comments: