The basis of this story is a clear misunderstanding: that one violates copyright law by putting music from a bought CD onto his or her computer. This is simply not true, as stated by Kerry Sherman of the RIAA and (according to Sherman) as pointed out even by some of the RIAA’s staunchest critics. If this were true, then how would someone play music on their computer at all (aside from the oligopoly that exists amongst iTunes, WMP Urge, RealPlayer, etc.)? Of course putting a CD onto a computer is not illegal. I myself never realized that this concept was so ambiguous.
Treating the more disputable issue, I feel the need to argue both sides:
Copying music to a CD in order to distribute, whether for specific unit-profit or for the $free.99, is illegal because it takes away from the optimum profit of the record companies. Music is information, and the price of information and its methods of dictation have always had a price set by those originally distributing the authentic information.
Or is it art?
The value of art is up to the beholder, the consumer. Given that art is a talent whose fountain of creativity never runs dry, one could argue that the value of art is totally up to the audience due to the infinite ability for the artist, musician, or writer to always create something new; they are not depleted after creating a work of art. On the contrary, the value of art could be great due to its unique nature, time taken to create, rarity, longevity, and many other abstract qualities. These aspects are all mostly dictated by the artist, but the audience can tell if one or more of these categories is lacking. As long as they aren’t, people might be willing to buy it.
Pretty much, if it’s quality (and one of your fav artists), you’ll probably buy it; it might have some sentimental value, or you just might like the cover art. E.G: you buy Thriller, you rip Soulja Boy. C’mon RIAA, we know standards when we see them- don’t get mad when people refuse to buy BS (Personally, I feel like many artist today are just taking advantage of the more available media opportunities- because of advances in technology- to get over on us and make a buck by throwing some ish together and calling it art/music. This is sooooo blatantly prevalent nowadays, and I- as a fellow artist and musician- am personally offended). The BS I speak of is usually fad music, music whose appeal will be clearly short-lived. People will always refuse to invest money in anything whose appeal depreciates so swiftly.
Plus, I wonder what Sherman’s pay stub looks like anyway…
1 comment:
You were totally reading my mind when you wrote this, lol! I did buy Thriller, and I did rip Soulja Boy. The Thriller album by Michael Jackson is truly a work of art; that album was originally released over 20 years ago, and people still jam to it today. Soulja Boy, on the other hand, will be over by 2010, if not sooner, meaning I will not waste my money on that crap. I will just rip it, do the Soulja Boy 10 times, and be ready for the next fad.
I love your whole information versus art with regard to music debate in this blog entry. I interpreted it like this: music is either information or art, depending upon how you approach it. If it is information, you pay the set price for it. If it is art, its value is up to you, the consumer. According to the dictionary, information is knowledge derived from study, experience, or instruction, and art is the conscious production or arrangement of sounds, colors, forms, movements, or other elements in a manner that affects the sense of beauty, specifically the production of the beautiful in a graphic or plastic medium. Can information be art or become art? If so, music will always be art and not necessarily information, meaning the value of the music is up to me, the consumer, and in my opinion, most music today is NOT of any value and leaves me longing for the ‘80’s and ‘90’s.
All in all, copying music to your computer from a CD should be legal. I believe that the deeper issue at hand is that fact that the recording industry is failing right now, in terms of capital, and there is no known solution other than to sue consumers for the slightest of things. The recording industry would be better off if more quality music, rather than fad music, is produced. My advice to the RIAA: fix your internal problems; do not blame the consumer for your lack of quality producing artists.
Post a Comment